Writer: Geoff Johns
Penciller: Jim Lee
Inker: Scott Williams, Mark Irwin & Jonathan Glapion
Colorist: Alex Sinclair, Gabe Eltaeb, Tony Avina & HiFi
Letterer: Patrick Brosseau
Editor: Brian Cunningham
Batman calls the Justice League together to inform them that someone has been assaulting and torturing their foes in order to learn more about them, but the heroes soon realize that they have too many secrets from one another to work effectively as a team. Their new foe,
Graves, uses a stolen access code
to break into the Watchtower and attacks the League, forcing them to confront
their misery; all in the name of making them pay for killing Graves’
Page 1: “Three Years Ago.” This scene takes place a year after last issue’s flashback. How is David Graves climbing in the mountains now, when he was all crippled and confined to a wheelchair back then?
are a mountain range in Pamir Mountains Central Asia formed by the
junction of the Himalayas, Tian Shan,
Karakoram, Kunlun and Hindu Kush
ranges. They are among the highest
mountains and have been since Victorian times, been known as the “Roof of the
Sumeru is the name of the central world-mountain in Buddhist cosmology and is considered to be the center of all the physical, metaphysical and spiritual universes.
|These big, multi-faced, multi-armed guys are the Asuras. In Hinduism, they are a group of power-seeking deities, usually considered sinful and materialistic, and are often opposed by the Devas.|
Graves captured and
tortured Steve Trevor last issue. Not
sure where Graves has been keeping Trevor, though. Looks like an abandoned warehouse of some
|Who exactly is talking to Trevor here? Is it, as Graves seems to think, his wife and kids, or something else entirely?|
Page 6: Is Aquaman lifting that whole damn ship by himself? How strong is he these days anyway?
Did this shipwreck occur near
? Is that his lighthouse in the background, or
just another of the many that dot the Amnesty
Bay New England coast?
Page 7: “Why’d the pick you as a member of the Justice League? Was it just right place, right time?” A running theme in the pages of Aquaman is that he gets little to no respect from the public, being the butt of everyone’s jokes for being “the guy who talks to fish,” despite being a total bad-ass.
As for membership in the Justice League…it was pretty much “right place, right time” for everyone.
“Like Vibe.” A reference to Vibe, real name Paco Ramone, who has yet to appear in the New 52 DCU, but is apparently active as a hero. As seen in DC Comics -- The New 52 F
CBD Special Edition #1, he will apparently
play a part in the upcoming Trinity War.
“Batman says to hit the teleporters. He wants us up at the Watchtower.” Where are the Justice League teleporters located? Are they at a central location or scattered around the country?
And, on that note, is Batman in charge of the Justice League? He seems to be the one that calls them all together. Recall how, at the end of Justice League #8, as the group walked through the Watchtower, they all seemed to follow Batman as if he were their leader.
|Since when does Batman "ask" anyone to do anything?|
First appearance of Vulko. First historical appearance in The Brave and the Bold (first series) #73. The chief scientific advisor of Atlantis, and ally of Aquaman.
Aquaman’s flashback illustrates how much of a “fish out of water” he truly is. He doesn’t feel accepted on the surface any more than he does in Atlantis. Vulko attempts to counsel him, and reminds him that it is ultimately his responsibility to be the Atlantean king.
Page 8: The Weapons Master and the Key appeared in Justice League #10. The Scarecrow first appeared in Batman (New 52) #1, Captain Cold in The Flash (New 52) #3. Scavenger and the Cheetah have yet to appear in the New 52
Page 9: “Because now
knows everything about us.” As seen in Justice League #9, Graves
interrogated the Key and the Weapons Master about the Justice League. But I think that Cyborg is overstating
things; Graves knows everything that all of these
villains know about the League, but not necessarily everything there is to know
|And, filling the role of overconfident, cocky Justice Leaguer is Green Lantern...|
|Man, Barry, with friends like Hal, who needs Rogues?|
Graves knows about the woman on the
Apache reservation who Wonder Woman visits every month.” Who is this mysterious Apache woman? And how does the Cheetah know about her?
“I thought your mother lived on
?” She did.
At least until recently. We’ll
get to that later. Paradise
Interesting to see how much these Leaguers don’t know about one another, isn’t it?
|A friend. Yeah. Right. Sure he is.|
Graves doesn’t know everything. Batman trusts me.” It’s good to see that this “friendship” has
been preserved to an extent. But why,
out of all the heroes on the team does Batman trust Superman? Does he truly like working with the Man of
Steel, or is the Dark Knight just keeping tabs on him?
Page 10: “And I’d like to say I trust you, Superman, but I don’t know a thing about you.” Difficult as it is to believe, Superman seems to be even more secretive than Batman, and that’s saying a lot.
“You seem like a nice guy. You say the right things when you do talk. But you’re always floating behind us.” The New 52
Superman is far more aloof and “alien” than his previous incarnation. He’s still trying to figure out his place in
the world and on the team.
|Not sure if you could handle Catwoman or Talia al Ghul, Superman, but you are more than welcome to try...|
Superman and Batman were seen working together in Justice League #9.
Page 11: “If it can be found on a computer, it can be found in my head.” Which makes Cyborg pretty darn powerful, now doesn’t it?
“Which is in the trash.” Anyone surprised that Hal Jordan has a crappy credit score? Anyone? Anyone?
“You’re worse than the Martian.” The Justice League’s history and conflict with the Martian Mahunter was only hinted at in Justice League #8, but things didn’t seem to end well. Regardless, this seems to be a very xenophobic thing for Green Lantern to say, especially since he regularly hangs out with aliens of all shapes and sizes.
|A reminder that Cyborg can't have either a normal life or a secret identity like the others can.|
“So, some of us know each other’s secrets, and some of us are still in the dark.” Let’s take a moment to recap who knows what, shall we?
Presumably, Cyborg knows pretty much everything about everyone else, or at least has access to that knowledge. Whether he consciously knows it all has yet to be seen. And everyone seems to know that he is Victor Stone.
I’d imagine that Batman knows everyone’s identities and secrets, being that he is Batman. Justice League #9 confirmed that he and Superman know one another’s identities, and regularly work together.
Superman seems to be an enigma to everyone else.
The Flash and Green Lantern worked together before the League was formed, as seen in Justice League #2, and know one another’s identities. Green Lantern knows that Batman is Bruce Wayne, since Batman unmasked before him in Justice League #5, but it doesn’t seem like he shared this information with the rest of the team.
Wonder Woman and Aquaman seem to be on the short end of the stick. They don’t seem to have secret identities, and their lives are pretty public, but they don’t know much about anyone else.
|This current story line examines how the Justice League works versus how it should work. Just because the League is seen as "the world's greatest super-heroes" doesn't mean that it is.|
In my mind, this story would work much better had the League been operating for a year, maybe two. To be a group for five years and only now is its members questioning the fact that they know next to nothing about one another strikes me as strange. But I guess this is the trade off for having a five-year timeline so that DC history isn't completely eradicated; personally I would have rather they just went with a full-on reboot in the first place, but no one at DC listens to me these days…
“In case someone tried to force one out of him.” The access code that Trevor gave to
in Justice League #9 was a fake to
warn the team of danger.
Page 12: “You can’t see anything bad happening from way up here.” It almost seems like
wants to make the Justice League better, kind of like Hunter Zolomon, a.k.a
Zoom from Geoff John’s The Flash run
|They have absolutely no idea who Graves is, do they? Nope, not a one.|
|Yeah. Steve's just a "friend." Right. Keep telling yourself that, Diana...|
Graves draws upon the
Leaguers’ misery and fears to incapacitate them.
|As seen in Wonder Woman (New 52) #4, Hera transformed Hippolyta and the Amazons of Paradise Island to stone.|
Page 16: Yep, Batman’s in charge. Or, at least, he thinks he is.
Page 18: What do the Asuras do to
and why? They must have some sort of
agenda to give him so much power.
|So are those actually Graves' wife and kids, or something else posing as them in order to manipulate Graves to do its bidding?|
|"Pa" refers to Jonathan "Pa" Kent,. Clark Kent's adoptive father, who died of a heart attack before Clark came to Metropolis.|
“The Justice League killed my family.” You keep saying this, Mr. Graves, but how exactly did they do this?
Page 20: Whoa, when was Batman taken out? He doesn’t even merit a panel or being overwhelmed by misery and grief?
Writer: Geoff Johns
Artist: Gary Frank
Colorist: Brad Anderson
Letterer: Nick J. Napolitano
Editor: Brian Cunningham
After Billy Batson sneaks out in the middle of the night to feed his “friend” Tawny a burger, he and Freddy Freeman get a little closer to being actual friends. Meanwhile, Doctor Sivana uses his ability to see magic to free Black Adam from his ages of imprisonment…
|Both Vasquezes were in the foster care system, which is why it is so important to them to take in kids that need their help.|
“Maybe with time it’ll get better. You remember Mary when she first came here.” Was she a problem child too? Was she wearing goth clothes and getting strung out on magic, hanging out with dark gods and trying to take over the world? Oh, wait, sorry, that was pre-Flashpoint. I always get confused…
|How does anyone sneak out of the house with noisy steps as noisy as these?|
|To what does that graffiti refer? Alice in Wonderland, perhaps? Is Billy due for a trip down the rabbit hole sometime soon?|
Page 25: Tawny is the zoo tiger, with whom Billy has a strange and probably one-sided friendship.
|The photograph of Billy's mom and dad sitting in front of Tawny's cage was seen in Justice League #8.|
Page 27: “Thanks for decking the Bryer brothers today, by the way.” Billy defends his new siblings from the Bryer brothers in Justice League #9.
Page 28: So good to see Freddy and Billy making nice-nice.
Page 29: “This way! Hahahaha!” It’s official, Sivana’s gone off the deep end…
Page 30: “I can see right through the magic attempting to conceal it.” Due to the events of Justice League #9, Sivana can now see magic.
|How is the Language of Eternity connected to the Circle of Eternity, which was first seen in DC Comics -- The New 52 FCBD Special Edition #1?|
“…Shazam!” So what does “Shazam” even mean these days? If it’s not the name of the Wizard, then what is it?
Page 32: First appearance of Black Adam. First historical appearance in The Marvel Family #1. Real name Teth-Adam. Possesses magically-bestowed superhuman stamina, speed, strength, wisdom, power and courage. Previously seen in a flash-forward in DC Comics -- The New 52 FCBD Special Edition #1.
What Wizard? Oh, you mean the
Wizard that was part of the Circle of Eternity, gave you powers, and then
exiled you for thousand of years? That
the Wizard you’re talking about?
He’s at the Rock of Eternity, but I must warn you, he hasn’t aged very well…